The episode starts with Carly walking in on Spencer doing some random silly, possibly unscripted, thing. Writer: Dan Schneider and Matt Fleckenstein This, is iLost My Mind (What an appropriate title) So without further ado, let’s really dive into why this arc was a mistake with an episode too stupid, even for this show. It’s more important that they screwed this one up too. iCantTakeIt has more problems but these problems bugged me more. This is for two reasons: I have less crap to explain if I do an earlier one, and it pissed me off the most. I decided go with the 2 nd episode in the arc, the one were they officially got together. Now I could have covered any of the other episodes since they each have notable problems, but I’ll go over them near the end. That would be fine if that was fixed in the other episodes. No explanation of why she likes him despite all she’s done or anything. And also that title.Īt the end, they find out Sam likes Freddie and they have a moment where they kiss and Carly sees it. It’s biggest problem is introducing this idea. I can rant on how it was all pointless and whatever, but my biggest issue was the set up and the middle of it. Honestly, I can say a lot about all this but I want to focus on one certain episode, and the main issues here. This arc lasted about 5 episodes until they just broke them up and didn’t go back to it again. It would be hard to convince us to like this idea Their “Rivalry” had gotten so bad, them actually liking each other seemed like a thing of the past. The main problem is how it just doesn’t work at this point. There’s a lot wrong with this even before we get into the episodes. Which is fair enough…then…they decided to bow down to the shippers and put these two together.

It got to the point where they made iStart a Fan War to tell the fans to calm down, as the show is just about silly dumb and mostly not romance. No matter how bad they got, the Seddie pairing was still popular to the point of starting big ship wars with Creddie, the ship that makes more sense.

And because that actually turned out well, it became a popular ship. Yet early on, they hinted at a possible romantic connection with iKiss.

Hell, even early on we had the Fred episode that shall not be named. He has his nerdy aspects but as the show went on it, it just got….bad I say sort of because while it was fair at first, it quickly turned into Sam just bullying Freddie for …no reason really. You can just see where he started to lose his touch a bit as the show went on, and the episode we’re talking about really showed that.Īnyway in the show Sam and Freddie had sort of a rivalry. I feel like it’s the transition period for Dan Schneider.Įarly on, it was good enough, by the end it was…not, mostly. First off, not too much to say about iCarly itself that hasn’t been said. My friends, it’s time to talk about the Seddie Arc, but first some backstory. Well…i found one, and I knew at the time that at least one ep from this arc could fit, but I wasn’t sure at the time.īut I’m getting ahead of myself. I can’t remember what review it was, but I think I said I hadn’t found an iCarly episode I could review, that hasn’t quite been covered in detail yet. Since we’ve been doing newer episodes lately so let’s go back a bit…to 2011. Well, not quite a surprise since it’s something I tweeted about when I saw it, but I didn’t have plans to do it at the time.

Icarly ilost my mind